Most buyers mistakenly assume that all soft plastics in Monkey Milk share the same durability. After analyzing user feedback across the board, I find that the plastic density varies significantly between these specific models. I have compared these six options to help you choose the right profile for your setup. Read on for my honest rankings and the specific scenarios where each crappie jig truly shines.
| Best For | Product | Name | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| High Volume Anglers |  |
Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50-Count Bulk Pack – Monkey Milk – 2" | 9.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Quick Tackle Runs |  |
Bobby Garland The Original 2" Baby Shad Soft Plastic Fishing Lure, Fishing Gear and Accessories, 18 per Pack, Monkey Milk | 9.5/10 | View on Amazon |
| Long Distance Casting |  |
Bobby Garland Stroll'R Soft Plastic Crappie Fishing Lure, Fishing Gear and Accessories, 2.5", Pack of 12, Monkey Milk | 9.2/10 | View on Amazon |
| Precise Vertical Jigging |  |
Bobby Garland Minnow Mind'R Soft Plastic Crappie Fishing Lure, Accessories for Freshwater Fishing, 2.25", Pack of 12, Monkey Milk | 8.9/10 | View on Amazon |
| Finesse Winter Fishing |  |
Bobby Garland Itty Bit Mayfly – Monkey Milk – 1.25" | 8.6/10 | View on Amazon |
| Active Retrieve Styles |  |
Bobby Garland Swimming Minnow Soft Plastic Crappie Fishing Lure, Fishing Gear and Accessories, 2", Pack of 15, Monkey Milk | 8.2/10 | View on Amazon |
1. Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50-Count Bulk Pack – Monkey Milk – 2"
This pack claims the top spot because it offers the most economical route for anglers who burn through lures quickly. By packaging 50 units together, you avoid the recurring cost of smaller retail bags.
In my view, this is the essential workhorse for anyone serious about crappie fishing. The profile remains the gold standard for versatility in various water clarities.
Buyers frequently mention that the bulk quantity provides better long-term value.
The 2-inch profile is widely considered the most reliable size for consistent strikes.
Frequent users note that maintaining a large inventory reduces the stress of running out mid-trip.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Bobby Garland The Original 2" Baby Shad Soft Plastic Fishing Lure, Fishing Gear and Accessories, 18 per Pack, Monkey Milk
This package is perfect for the angler who prefers quick tackle runs and only needs a small stash for the weekend. It avoids the commitment of a large bulk purchase while delivering the exact same proven design.
I appreciate this size for keeping my light tackle bag organized without unnecessary clutter. It is the perfect starter pack if you want to verify the effectiveness of the Monkey Milk color before buying in bulk.
Users often select this for short-notice trips where they only need a few spares.
The 18-count pack fits easily into standard tackle boxes and vest pockets.
Many find this quantity ideal for rotating colors without overstocking one specific pattern.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Bobby Garland Stroll'R Soft Plastic Crappie Fishing Lure, Fishing Gear and Accessories, 2.5", Pack of 12, Monkey Milk
The most unexpected feature here is the unique tail design that creates a wide, rhythmic vibration during a retrieve. This design allows you to push water more effectively than a standard shad tail.
When you need to cover water, the extra 0.5 inches of length provides just enough presence to attract fish from a distance. I find this to be a superior choice when the bite is aggressive and you need to maximize your coverage area.
Anglers report that the longer body helps trigger reaction strikes from neutral fish.
The swimming action remains stable even at slightly higher retrieve speeds.
It is a popular choice for those who rely on long-distance casting to reach open water schools.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Bobby Garland Minnow Mind'R Soft Plastic Crappie Fishing Lure, Accessories for Freshwater Fishing, 2.25", Pack of 12, Monkey Milk
The most common complaint is the delicate connection point where the tail meets the body, which can be prone to tearing. However, this trade-off is necessary to achieve the subtle, high-frequency shivering motion that triggers lethargic crappie.
If you handle these with care, the precise action is often worth the extra attention. I would recommend this specifically for clear water where fish are watching your lure closely.
Buyers note that slow presentations often yield the best results with this model.
The 2.25-inch length offers a slimmer profile that mimics small baitfish perfectly.
Experienced users suggest using a light jig head to maintain the intended swimming posture.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Bobby Garland Itty Bit Mayfly – Monkey Milk – 1.25"
Compared to the Minnow Mind'R above, this jig is significantly smaller and better suited for micro-finesse tactics. While the Mind'R focuses on subtle swimming, the Mayfly excels at mimicking tiny aquatic insects during the dead of winter.
I prefer this option when the water temperature drops and the fish show zero interest in larger profiles. It provides the compact silhouette needed to coax a bite out of cold-stunned crappie.
It is highly effective for vertical presentations in deep, cold water.
The 1.25-inch size is often the only way to entice very inactive fish.
Many anglers keep these on hand specifically for tough conditions when standard sizes fail.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
6. Bobby Garland Swimming Minnow Soft Plastic Crappie Fishing Lure, Fishing Gear and Accessories, 2", Pack of 15, Monkey Milk
This lure gained its reputation as an all-around performer, and my assessment is that it still holds up as a reliable, active retrieve tool. It provides a more traditional minnow imitation than the shad-style baits, which helps when the fish are keyed into specific prey.
If you enjoy a steady retrieve, the paddle tail delivers a consistent thump that cuts through murky water. It remains a dependable staple for any angler who likes to keep their lure moving.
It works well for searching active fish along brush piles and docks.
The 15-count pack strikes a balance between portability and enough supply for a full day.
Users often praise the durability of the plastic during steady-retrieve scenarios.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
For the high-volume angler, I recommend the Bobby Garland Baby Shad bulk pack as the primary choice for its consistent value. If you are a weekend hobbyist, the 18-pack Original provides exactly what you need for short trips, while the Stroll'R is my top suggestion for those who prioritize distance casting. For the specialized crowd, the Itty Bit Mayfly is an essential piece of winter gear, and the Minnow Mind'R serves the finesse vertical angler perfectly.
Please be aware that these soft plastics are formulated for high action, which means they can be somewhat fragile. Whether you choose the high-volume bulk pack or the more specialized designs, remember to use a gentle touch when rigging to avoid premature tearing. A little extra care ensures these lures perform exactly as intended.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.
